CNN | The struggle to contain the coronavirus pandemic is opening a new front in the long-running conflict between blue cities and red states.
Across
a wide array of states with Republican governors, many of the largest
cities and counties -- most of them led by Democrats -- are moving
aggressively to limit economic and social activity. State officials,
meanwhile, are refusing to impose the strictest statewide standards to fight the virus.
A
growing chorus of big-city officials in red states like Florida,
Georgia, Mississippi and Missouri are now urging their governors to
establish uniform statewide rules, arguing that refusing to do so
undercuts their local initiatives by increasing the risk the disease will cluster in neighboring areas -- from which it can easily reinfect their populations.
On Tuesday afternoon, after weeks of
complaints from local officials and medical officials, Republican Texas
Gov. Greg Abbott issued a statewide order restricting social
interactions to essential activities (albeit with some conspicuous
exceptions).
Robyn
Tannehill, the mayor of Oxford, Mississippi (home of the University of
Mississippi), told me in an interview that the absence of a statewide
rule was undercutting their local efforts to control social interaction.
"As
we are a regional health care and shopping destination, we have people
coming through from surrounding counties that are not [imposing] a stay
at home order," she said. "When they come here, you don't know who you
are passing in the Kroger or the Walmart. ... I think a statewide
stay-at-home order is very necessary."
The
Republican governors most resisting statewide action have almost all
argued that smaller counties should not face the same restrictions as
larger ones. "What may be right for places like the large urban areas
may not be right at this particular point in time for the" smaller
counties with fewer cases, Abbott said last week before relenting on Tuesday.
While
echoing that logic, other GOP governors resisting calls for action from
large cities have also cited more ideological arguments. Mississippi Gov. Tate Reeves
last week painted extensive shut-down orders as an expression of overly
intrusive government. "In times such as these, you always have experts
who believe they know best for everybody," he said. "You have some folks
who think that government ought to take over everything in times of
crisis — that they, as government officials, know better than individual
citizens."
Similarly, Missouri's GOP governor, Mike Parson,
argued that rather than government action "it is going to be personal
responsibility" that wins the struggle against the virus.
0 comments:
Post a Comment