NYTimes | FOR
more than two centuries, we have been reading the Declaration of
Independence wrong. Or rather, we’ve been celebrating the Declaration as
people in the 19th and 20th centuries have told us we should, but not
the Declaration as Thomas Jefferson, Benjamin Franklin and John Adams
wrote it. To them, separation from Britain was as much, if not more,
about racial fear and exclusion as it was about inalienable rights.
The Declaration’s beautiful preamble distracts us from the heart of the document, the 27 accusations
against King George III over which its authors wrangled and debated,
trying to get the wording just right. The very last one — the ultimate
deal-breaker — was the most important for them, and it is for us: “He
has excited domestic insurrections amongst us, and has endeavored to
bring on the inhabitants of our frontiers, the merciless Indian savages,
whose known rule of warfare is an undistinguished destruction of all
ages, sexes and conditions.” In the context of the 18th century,
“domestic insurrections” refers to rebellious slaves. “Merciless Indian
savages” doesn’t need much explanation.
In fact, Jefferson had originally included an extended attack
on the king for forcing slavery upon unwitting colonists. Had it stood,
it would have been the patriots’ most powerful critique of slavery. The
Continental Congress cut out all references to slavery as “piratical
warfare” and an “assemblage of horrors,” and left only the sentiment
that King George was “now exciting those very people to rise in arms
among us.” The Declaration could have been what we yearn for it to be, a
statement of universal rights, but it wasn’t. What became the official
version was one marked by division.
Upon
hearing the news that the Congress had just declared American
independence, a group of people gathered in the tiny village of
Huntington, N.Y., to observe the occasion by creating an effigy of King
George. But before torching the tyrant, the Long Islanders did something
odd, at least to us. According to a report in a New York City
newspaper, first they blackened his face, and then, alongside his wooden
crown, they stuck his head “full of feathers” like “savages,” wrapped
his body in the Union Jack, lined it with gunpowder and then set it
ablaze.
0 comments:
Post a Comment