Monday, June 30, 2014

what "god" does to your brain...,


vancouversun |  When neuroscientist Andrew Newberg scanned the brain of “Kevin,” a staunch atheist, while he was meditating, he made a fascinating discovery. “Compared with the Buddhist monks and Franciscan nuns, whose brains I’d also scanned, Kevin’s brain operated in a significantly different way,” he says.

“He had far more activity in the prefrontal cortex, the area that controls emotional feelings and mediates attention. Kevin’s brain appeared to be functioning in a highly analytical way, even when he was in a resting state.”

Would Newberg find something similar if he scanned my brain? I, too, am an atheist. This is largely the result of my upbringing (my father is a theoretical physicist, who, as a former director general of Cern, set up the Large Hadron Collider that is searching for the Higgs boson, or so-called “God” particle – though many physicists loathe that phrase), but also of prolonged investigations into other religions to see if I was “missing” something central to billions of people worldwide.
When people speak in tongues, they’re gone, they’re in a completely altered state. But most of the time they’re normal people like us
In this spirit, several years ago, I attended an “Alpha” course, a 10-week introduction to evangelical Christianity. It utterly failed to convince me but, during a service, another “recruit,” Mark, fell to his knees, babbling “in tongues.” When he came round, he was convinced he had been possessed by the Holy Spirit. I watched, bemused. Why had he entered this transcendental state, while I was completely unmoved? Was he deluded, or was he genuinely a conduit of God? Or were our brains simply wired differently?

“When people speak in tongues, they’re gone, they’re in a completely altered state. But most of the time they’re normal people like us, with jobs and children – they don’t show any sign of being delusional,” says Newberg. “Scans of their brains – when they’re ’possessed’ – show very different results to scans of Buddhist monks or Carmelite nuns in prayer or meditation. There you see increased frontal lobe activity in the areas concerned with concentration, but the speakers in tongues had decreased activity in the same area, which would give them the sensation that someone else was ’running the show’.”

And what about me? “I wouldn’t be surprised if you have a harder time letting go of frontal lobe activity, so you tend to observe and take a more critical eye of events, while other people’s brains allow them to simply surrender to events around them.”

5 comments:

BigDonOne said...

"Why had he entered this transcendental state, while I was completely unmoved? "
The guy was obviously a shill of the Alpha course organization, a good actor, inserted among the class for hype and proselytization purposes. The church is a *business* and they need a continuous stream of suckers donating to fund the operattion. There is not a shred of credible testable evidence of any Truth to it. Folks pay to be duped into 'feeling good...'

CNu said...

Or, perhaps Big Don is simply lacking the “God gene” or VMAT2, to be
precise, that controls the flow of mood–regulating chemicals, called
monoamines, in the brain. According to U.S. molecular geneticist Dr Dean
Hamer, subjects with this gene were more susceptible to
self-transcendent, spiritual experiences. Many neuroscientists now think
spiritual tendencies involve genes relating to the brain’s dopamine and
serotonin neurotransmitters.http://www.vancouversun.com/life/What+does+your+brain+Controversial+science+neurotheology+aims/9977473/story.html

Vic78 said...

There's a lot more to it than what they're saying. They should check the brains of deconverts of various systems. This research looks promising.

CNu said...

lol, of course there is. There's a gaping, mushroom-shaped hole in the exact center of all this hooha, which hole, if properly filled - would democratically yield a direct experience of "god-within" http://subrealism.blogspot.com/search?q=eucharist

BigDonOne said...

It is indeed refreshing to observe CNu acknowledging that genetics can control behavior....

Fuck Robert Kagan And Would He Please Now Just Go Quietly Burn In Hell?

politico | The Washington Post on Friday announced it will no longer endorse presidential candidates, breaking decades of tradition in a...