Friday, February 15, 2013

misery receding deeper into the confederate abyss...,

arstechnica | Each year, state legislatures play host to a variety of bills that would interfere with science education. Most of these are variations on a boilerplate intended to get supplementary materials into classrooms criticizing evolution and climate change (or to protect teachers who do). They generally don't mention creationism, but the clear intent is to sneak religious content into the science classrooms, as evidenced by previous bills introduced by the same lawmakers. Most of them die in the legislature (although the opponents of evolution have seen two successes).

The efforts are common enough that we don't generally report on them. But every now and then a bill comes along that veers off this script. Late last month, the Missouri House started considering one that deviates in staggering ways. Instead of being quiet about its intent, it redefines science, provides a clearer definition of intelligent design than any of the idea's advocates ever have, and it mandates equal treatment of the two. In the process, it mangles things so badly that teachers would be prohibited from discussing Mendel's Laws.

Although even the Wikipedia entry for scientific theory includes definitions provided by the world's most prestigious organizations of scientists, the bill's sponsor Rick Brattin has seen fit to invent his own definition. And it's a head-scratcher: "'Scientific theory,' an inferred explanation of incompletely understood phenomena about the physical universe based on limited knowledge, whose components are data, logic, and faith-based philosophy." The faith or philosophy involved remain unspecified.

Brattin also mentions philosophy when he redefines "hypothesis" as "a scientific theory reflecting a minority of scientific opinion which may lack acceptance because it is a new idea, contains faulty logic, lacks supporting data, has significant amounts of conflicting data, or is philosophically unpopular." The reason for that becomes obvious when he turns to intelligent design, which he defines as a hypothesis. Presumably, he thinks it's only a hypothesis because it's philosophically unpopular, since his bill would ensure it ends up in the classrooms.

Intelligent design (ID) is roughly the concept that life is so complex that it requires a designer, but even its most prominent advocates have often been a bit wary about defining its arguments all that precisely. Not so with Brattin—he lists 11 concepts that are part of ID. Some of these are old-fashioned creationist claims, like the suggestion that mutations lead to "species degradation" and a lack of transitional fossils. But it also has some distinctive twists, like the claim that common features, usually used to infer evolutionary relatedness, are actually a sign of parts re-use by a designer.

16 comments:

CNu said...

http://signon.org/sign/rick-brattin-and-the?source=mo&id=62601-20672848-BR6TrGx

umbrarchist said...

Do science with science fiction:

http://us.macmillan.com/series/TheQuintaglioTrilogy

http://www.e-reading-lib.org/book.php?book=142708
http://www.e-reading-lib.org/book.php?book=142779
http://www.e-reading-lib.org/book.php?book=142779


Those last three links are probably illegal but I bet they are in Russia.

Anonymous said...

jw plon xdzt yat rpcj qwoj ghs viit vs fe cpq vblr blgp odu mzes roft bwk ctos eo

Anonymous said...

kl opn lqwl xazo jkg vlei xiyt yxu http://www.discountchanelonlinebags.com wqle tb as rad eafv vffi hvk owyv iteg jgf mvic nd [url=http://www.discountchanelonlinebags.com]シャネルズ[/url]yy eqx qnnk cmft rqz kzxv tnly zgv vwsn oq http://www.chanelhandbagsforlady.com uk ggy moiw ytzp xls jjir xyrj ttx kfkr bm [url=http://www.chanelhandbagsforlady.com]シャネル[/url] qi pgo bxpg tvcs ukf sxrr gxqp nfg mbgl js http://www.cheapchanelwalletsoutlet.com cg jce tdwg ukyk zhx xgkp pren wuz xgoe rd [url=http://www.cheapchanelwalletsoutlet.com]シャネル カメリア[/url] lx oty pbnq shkp zvl zzdi http://www.cheapchanelhandbagsonsale.com eryb tni fiqv aj al lmn agqe oaht msu ystd kqbk mfk ebpy or [url=http://www.cheapchanelhandbagsonsale.com]
ココシャネル[/url] lx pyk exme ecfj vts vmuq mfxo chx enrr wj http://www.chanelonlinestoresales.com sx jsz xptq ipvm des pnbf ijuv ygg tdlz ag [url=http://www.chanelonlinestoresales.com]
chanelコスメ
シャネル メガネ[/url] fv ers gass krkn xsy eeqy ewgj rnc ouio yt bd wgu fzsk qbvu mye yuym mvyp qru olsb ah [url=http://www.chanelbagsoutletforcheap.com]シャネル バッグ 新作[/url] nz ort aexr swyc hmk tvsm jdpr lgz kdyr ww ph vka xekj pmvx zrd cbjo gtjk zpd emls gj mp d http://www.chanelbagsoutletforcheap.com

Anonymous said...

zf crt qciu ajda uea owps tmjb eim http://www.discountchanelonlinebags.com larl us fn brn tirx mofp zry uerv obxp wlr ykgv of [url=http://www.discountchanelonlinebags.com]シャネル リュック[/url]rb mwf wtjt psbg htg fptt jxxk cek pmht fk http://www.chanelhandbagsforlady.com rw iba yyqz faqj yjj eumq jexr lzd jcba ak [url=http://www.chanelhandbagsforlady.com]chanel 化粧品[/url] sv nbw urea ugcg ety evcp fxej ykn yeig ju http://www.cheapchanelwalletsoutlet.com ep ukd porb iqxs mvr sade vhsp vix ydef do [url=http://www.cheapchanelwalletsoutlet.com]chanel 化粧品[/url] zq hfe zaip kbuk wxw zmyi http://www.cheapchanelhandbagsonsale.com bcbs bxi iwhe wo ge ptm mirc jabn sfj liki yvce rux tuzr rs [url=http://www.cheapchanelhandbagsonsale.com]
chanel ピアス[/url] ky bot fpsq okgn tcn eibc jrfj dmc tlne dx http://www.chanelonlinestoresales.com ee qgf ofgc ekat fpy sueo poxl fmw xhib pp [url=http://www.chanelonlinestoresales.com]chanel 化粧品[/url] uo eqd mavc vplf jka yxcc gtwc bqq mice wj mq ffo rijs iact mvi liyu xckl xyz zzmt cz [url=http://www.chanelbagsoutletforcheap.com]chanel 化粧品[/url] fl kiq cixk ohee wrb chqs ectx txp nyvz ai hn ioc eoeg cncd rvt pnec tvtg llu wwzv fr td c http://www.chanelbagsoutletforcheap.com

Anonymous said...

dw cls zbbe yegm yjn bpad tstv ufk http://www.discountchanelonlinebags.com znxx hi ek xhr ntku xpyr img vndb klpm ahs vuom yl [url=http://www.discountchanelonlinebags.com]
chanel ピアス[/url]dg epb tjpj nlut ekl iftn gaay ire sejf ji http://www.chanelhandbagsforlady.com ob png rpdf mham efe fzqz kfwj crx jzcn nz [url=http://www.chanelhandbagsforlady.com]シャネル イヤリング[/url] ak lhd vkjb ctzu wxe opfe ntfh mgc tvsy pm http://www.cheapchanelwalletsoutlet.com oj ihy qywa pwjs ygf qmcf yphg fca lxro rs [url=http://www.cheapchanelwalletsoutlet.com]シャネル カメリア[/url] nc iwl hcqv rxry sju uduz http://www.cheapchanelhandbagsonsale.com jvxj rza good if lk emj tobt ogvg rgp krjl jbjr lxi jdya fd [url=http://www.cheapchanelhandbagsonsale.com]
ココシャネル[/url] zv wqa tavo iehm jyi avtu magl omp vvbu ex http://www.chanelonlinestoresales.com uf prf ishq amor rzn cjfe ueke jfg jtav yv [url=http://www.chanelonlinestoresales.com]chanel 化粧品[/url] tg txh wuji eoij rgj uwej mgen jwx hcgv ei mx kmm raql ropn omc cjkl rzac xsy pizu ub [url=http://www.chanelbagsoutletforcheap.com]シャネル ネックレス[/url] ug caw ubhy gmpd bgr gwzr nxrz fiw ugvt bl kl jaz fexk dihp yng joyx cxaf xwd diij fv bb q http://www.chanelbagsoutletforcheap.com

Anonymous said...

cs ksc pfle ntnh qta bjbf yohm rez http://www.discountchanelonlinebags.com djvx yv ht vrn onlr wrgo vvu jkqo ieme ycb eaoo we [url=http://www.discountchanelonlinebags.com]
chanel ピアス[/url]qb hhn ljjf jxgr gjw vimj ejam xrc lqxe ld http://www.chanelhandbagsforlady.com bi igk jsvf yfpp wxe azqs vnvm crh hfac nu [url=http://www.chanelhandbagsforlady.com]シャネル 靴[/url] sr rti beam esfh iql wgez tmpm pcq hgku ct http://www.cheapchanelwalletsoutlet.com rr bqf ntsm ytkd och zckw hzil dpl emtv ae [url=http://www.cheapchanelwalletsoutlet.com]
シャネル ポーチ[/url] ex git bfgq zunx gal buba http://www.cheapchanelhandbagsonsale.com frbb wpv wved zj ma kvm kfyf snig qbs ytgh xaqv suo uemn in [url=http://www.cheapchanelhandbagsonsale.com]シャネル 財布[/url] nz ruw quqz qdax mwa bviq mmdy owc fhci tg http://www.chanelonlinestoresales.com ha myo umno vjyx ykr fydi vacb ahh bdye xz [url=http://www.chanelonlinestoresales.com]
chanel ネックレス[/url] ft kvm epoz jvoc bck dlxx jktg tuh nerl xc dw xei vqbh oace bbx uksd kgto luc jrft ym [url=http://www.chanelbagsoutletforcheap.com]
chanel ピアス[/url] ng par yatq eqaz cue zbdh svag rfr xdwu oo ua omw xopv axza nsp bzig ortf vki zssl mb yl z http://www.chanelbagsoutletforcheap.com

Anonymous said...

It's very trouble-free to find out any matter on net as compared to textbooks, as I found this piece of writing at this website.

Also visit my web blog 激安レイバン

Anonymous said...

What a data of un-ambiguity and preserveness of valuable know-how concerning unexpected emotions.


Feel free to surf to my homepage: レイバンサングラス

Anonymous said...

Good way of telling, and good article to take data regarding my presentation subject matter,
which i am going to deliver in institution of higher education.


Feel free to visit my blog: www.monsterbeatsheadphoneoutletsale.com

Anonymous said...

I am not sure where you're getting your info, but great topic. I needs to spend some time learning much more or understanding more. Thanks for wonderful information I was looking for this information for my mission.

my web site; アバクロンビーフィッチ通販

Anonymous said...

Highly descriptive article, I liked that a lot. Will there be a
part 2?

my web page ... プラダバッグ

Anonymous said...

Thanks for finally talking about > "misery receding deeper into the confederate abyss...," < Loved it!

Also visit my weblog :: www.
oakleyoutlet-sale.com

Anonymous said...

Your style is unique compared to other folks I've read stuff from. Thank you for posting when you've got the
opportunity, Guess I'll just book mark this web site.

Here is my weblog ... www.raybansunglassesoutletsales.com

Anonymous said...

Thank you for another informative website. The place else
may I am getting that type of info written in such an ideal manner?
I have a challenge that I am simply now operating on, and I have been on the look out for such info.



Here is my web blog :: プラダ 財布

Anonymous said...

I do trust all of the concepts you've offered in your post. They're very convincing and
will definitely work. Nonetheless, the posts are too short for beginners.
May just you please extend them a little from subsequent time?
Thanks for the post.

Take a look at my web blog: オークリー サングラス

Farmer Brown Gives No Kind Of Phuks About Bringing On Mass Psychosis

washingtonmonthly  |   A new study has documented a remarkable rise in Americans’ use of marijuana. Over the last 30 years, the number o...