nakedcapitalism | As readers know, I deprecate the (informal: disparaging and dffensive)
noun “illegals,” not only because it’s a slippery slope to “frugals,”
“orals,” “regals,” and so forth, but because I can’t think of a good
reason to insult people who are, often courageously, trying to improve
their own lives and those of their families. (“Scab,” of course, is
another pejorative for people with similar motives. So, for that matter,
is “banker.” It’s complicated!) In any case, it’s these migrants[1] presence
that’s illegal, not they themselves, so, heck, maybe it’s all just an
innocent case of metonymy…. In this post, I want to straighten out not
these, but another small kink in our political discourse, which shows up
when you read this story from the Times carefully. The headline:
An ICE Raid Leaves an Iowa Town Divided Along Faith Lines
Parenthetically, and just for the record, allow me to insert this
photo of a church congregation that became a crossroads for families and
supporters of the men detained in the workplace raid in that small
town:
I can’t quite put my finger on it, but I have the nagging feeling
there’s something about that picture inconsistent with an important
liberal Democrat construct, identity politics. Close parenthesis.
Immediately I asked, as one should ask, why is faith the
chosen dividing line? After all, you can slice and dice a human
population as many ways as you can a pineapple, or a cake. Could it be
that there’s another, more interesting “divide” that the reporter’s
choice elides?
The reporter, slicing the pineapple by faith, ignores the question of law. We know who is subject to the law: The migrants, caught up in the raid. Is there anybody in the story who is not subject to the law? Why, yes. Yes, there is:
The reporter, slicing the pineapple by faith, ignores the question of law. We know who is subject to the law: The migrants, caught up in the raid. Is there anybody in the story who is not subject to the law? Why, yes. Yes, there is:
No charges have been filed against the owners of the Midwest Precast Concrete plant in Mount Pleasant that was raided. An ICE spokesman declined to comment, citing a continuing investigation.So, the elite have impunity when they break the law; et in Mount Pleasant ego. We know this, of course, from the Crash, so no surprises here. Oddly, or not, the reporter, when interviewing business owners, doesn’t raise this point:
0 comments:
Post a Comment