NYTimes | A crucial question in the debate over income and wealth inequality is
whether its growth necessarily leads to a growth in the inequality of
political power. If it does, then this is a powerful reason for the
federal government to take active measures to reduce income and wealth
inequality — even if it comes at an economic cost to the nation.
Conservatives and libertarians generally do not believe that
increased inequality is a political or economic problem. To a large
extent, I think that is because they fear that acknowledging the problem
would require the adoption of policies they find distasteful, immoral
and economically counterproductive.
That is, income and wealth would have to be redistributed — taken via
taxation from the wealthy and given to the poor. The higher taxes will
reduce the incentive to work, save and invest among the wealthy,
conservatives and libertarians believe, which will reduce economic
growth and lead to the expatriation of the wealthy from the United
States, while fostering a culture of dependency among the poor that will
reduce their incentive to better themselves and escape poverty.
Insofar as the political dynamics are concerned, conservatives and
libertarians are generally fearful of democracy. That is because, in
principle, there is essentially no constraint on the ability of the
majority to take from the minority and reward themselves in a pure
democracy. The founding fathers very much shared this concern and
intentionally enacted numerous restraints on the majority to protect the
rights of the minority to their wealth. Among these are the federal
system, with relatively strong states and a weak national legislature,
as compared to parliamentary systems, and a Senate where small, sparsely
populated states, per capita, have more influence than large, populous
states; a written constitution with strong protection for property
rights; and an Electoral College instead of election of the president by
pure popular vote.
One reason that conservatives and libertarians obsess over the large
percentage of the population that pays no federal income taxes, often
put at 47 percent,
is the political concern that the nation is very close to a tipping
point where the have-nots can take from the haves almost at will.
0 comments:
Post a Comment