slate | The excuses are weak. In the words of the committee report,
“it is difficult to believe that Holder’s judgment would be so
monumentally poor that he could not understand how he was being
manipulated by Jack Quinn.” And presidential pardons don’t just slip
through like this, especially not pardons of wanted fugitives. If Holder
had followed protocols and made sure the Justice Department was looped
in, there’s no way that Rich would have been pardoned. Hundreds of
thousands of men sit in American prisons doing unconscionably long
sentences for nonviolent drug offenses. DNA tests routinely turn up
cases of unjust convictions. But Marc Rich bought his pardon with money
and access, and the committee’s response to that purchase is worth
quoting in full:
The President abused one his most important powers, meant to free the unjustly convicted or provide forgiveness to those who have served their time and changed their lives. Instead, he offered it up to wealthy fugitives whose money had already enabled them to permanently escape American justice. Few other abuses could so thoroughly undermine public trust in government.
But there was no real lasting damage to trust in government, or to
anyone’s reputation, really. Bill Clinton retired to wealth and
adulation. Eric Holder got his wish and eventually became attorney
general. And Marc Rich died a wealthy man in Switzerland. He never came
back to the United States—if he had returned, he would have been subject
to civil suits, which would have ended up costing him money—but he was
able to live out the rest of his life without having to worry about
being arrested, having bought his freedom from craven politicians who
were only too willing to sell.
