mises | The issue has been addressed with unsurpassed clarity by one of the foremost of all classical liberals, Ludwig von Mises.
The right of self-determination … thus means: whenever the inhabitants of a particular territory, whether it be a single village, a whole district, or a series of adjacent districts, make it known, by a freely conducted plebiscite, they no longer wish to remain united to the state to which they belong at the time … their wishes are to be respected and complied with.[5]
Mises emphasizes that this right
extends to the inhabitants of every territory large enough to form an
independent administrative unit. If it were in any way possible to grant this right of self-determination to every individual person, it would have to be done.[6]
Once one has grasped Mises's point, the fallacy in an often-heard argument is apparent. Some have held that the Southern states acted
"undemocratically" in refusing to accept the results of the election of 1860. Lincoln, after all, received a plurality of the country's popular vote.
To a Misesian, the answer is obvious: so what? A majority (much less a plurality) has no right to coerce dissenters. Further, the argument fails on its own terms. It was not undemocratic to secede. The Southern states did not deny that Lincoln was in fact the rightfully elected president. Rather, they wanted out just because he was. Democracy would oblige them only to acknowledge Lincoln's authority had they chosen to remain in the Union.
But a problem now arises. I have endeavored to defend secession from an individual-rights standpoint. Notoriously, Mises did not acknowledge natural rights. I fear that, like Jeremy Bentham, he regarded declarations of rights as "nonsense on stilts." Why, then, did Mises accept self-determination?
Mises's reasoning is characteristically incisive. If people are compelled to remain under a government they do not choose, then strife is the likely outcome. Recognition of the right to secede "is the only feasible and effective way of preventing revolutions and civil and international wars."[7] Mises's argument does not rest on natural rights, but it is of course consistent with the approach I have sketched out. Regardless of one's moral theory, it is surely a strong point in favor of a view that it has beneficial consequences.
Video - John Marco Allegro in an interview with Van Kooten & De Bie. TSMATC | Describing the growth of the mushroom ( boletos), P...
Recent Comments
ken
That was pretty shotty by whoever set the chat up. Of course we would have never heard anything had the reporter not been involved in the chat, but its still not very good. And had it been reversed...
Trump's early Feb idea of clearing out Gaza and developing it is never going to happen and is so far removed from the principle America First policy that we have to conclude that is a ploy to...
The Pritzker/Browder cadre has lost it's internecine civil war with the aggressive and overt oligarchic zionists. The Pritzker/Browder oy veys have been all-in on democratic cadre politics and...
Ukraine has no mineral wealth a white man is bound to acknowledge...., (if it did, it would've begun exploiting it to some extent years ago) Russia has $75 Trillion of proven mineral reserves...
I liked this guy's comment in the link you quoted from: Muhammad C. Author Founder & CEO / Mentor / Podcast-Host (soon) / I help Corporates innovate, build and scale Ventures and Venture...
The US isn't sending any more weapons, for defense-only, or otherwise, to Ukraine and Zelensky knows it. Z Cucaracha was trying to use the press conference to expose the "US...
Kaitlin didn't have an argument to Rubio's claim that Trump is the only person in the world that has a chance to negotiate for peace. Rubio laid that on her at about 13 minutes and she...
1/31 Again
-
When 1 = A and 26 = Z
Hypertiger = 131
Looks like the purpose of the Free Trade agreements in the past was to make
Canada and Mexico so dependent on ...
Announcing My 3rd Book
-
My latest book is now available for purchase! It is a bit different than my
prior works. It is entitled Becoming Missouri State: Conversations on the
Great...
Return of the Magi
-
Lately, the Holy Spirit is in the air. Emotional energy is swirling out of
the earth.I can feel it bubbling up, effervescing and evaporating around
us, s...
Covid-19 Preys Upon The Elderly And The Obese
-
sciencemag | This spring, after days of flulike symptoms and fever, a man
arrived at the emergency room at the University of Vermont Medical Center.
He ...
-
(Damn, has it been THAT long? I don't even know which prompts to use to
post this)
SeeNew
Can't get on your site because you've gone 'invite only'?
Man, ...
First Member of Chumph Cartel Goes to Jail
-
With the profligate racism of the Chumph Cartel, I don’t imagine any of
them convicted and jailed is going to do too much better than your run of
the mill ...