waisworld | Today, in the middle of the biggest military operation undertaken during
this war by the Ukrainians, about which nothing, bizarrely, is reported
in the Western press, the official spokesman of Zelensky, Oleksiy
Arestovich, published a remarkably passionate (possibly not sober)
diatribe against Ukrainian nationalists on the same Russian-language
Telegram feed where he publishes Zelensky's daily briefings (which I
read every day), among other things blaming them (Ukrainian
nationalists) for the Russian invasion.
Some excerpts:
"The ‘patriotic forces' of Ukraine (as they proudly call themselves) have never gained more than 1.5% in elections.
"The [Ukrainian] people are gray, but wise. The people understand that
these comrades should not be entrusted with state power under any
circumstances. In general, in none. There is simply no such case.
"Yesterday, I noted with true satisfaction how wise our people
are--watching the reaction of the ‘patriotic spirit' to the creation of
the Political Center of the Russian militant opposition to the Putin
regime, headed by Ilya Ponamarev.
"I didn't fully understand before how you can be headless and narrow-minded at the same time. They managed to show me, bravo.
"I got a sensual understanding of how Ukrainian statehood has been f***d
up until now--over and over again, for several hundred years in a row.
"It's very simple--they allowed ‘this' and ‘these' [Ukrainian nationalists] to make real state decisions.
"The reaction is simple:
"--‘we don't need opposition to Putin here, f*** off to the Russian
Federation, and we will close ourselves up here in the Motherland, we
will love each other and write.'
"These, God forgive me, motherf*****s [I struggle to translate the
colorful and fundamentally untranslatable Russian obscenity
"dolboeb"--CS], are the quintessence of eternal Ukrainian defeats.
"You say--‘motherf*****s' is too strong. These are volunteers, activists, patriots.'
"Yes. These are volunteers, activists, patriots. And--mother****s.
"It's good that not all volunteers, activists and patriots are morons.
"I would even say that the morons are in the minority.
"It seems to you, and most importantly--to them, that there are a lot of them. It's an illusion.
"They are just loud. And they are noisy because the weakest screams the loudest.
"These are jerky, weak-willed, extremely selfish creatures, shriveled up
in a strange mixture of hatred and envy for each other and a terrible
resentment for the rest of the environment.
"The political center of militant opposition to Putin in Ukraine is influence. Our influence on the Russian Federation.
"Only a mother**** can voluntarily renounce influence.
"They renounce. Everything is logical.
"At one time, Skoropadsky [the puppet Hetman of Ukraine at one point,
appointed by German occupiers during WWI, a weird reference--CS] was
ashamed to wipe his boots on this audience. As a result, we got here the
Kiev Cheka, and a little later--the Holodomor.
"We could have become Finland. Instead we became a republic of the USSR.
"Today we have Putin's invasion, because it is this herd that poisons
Ukraine and deprives it of real strength and influence--a small, farm
herd trying to escape from reality under the plausible pretext of
‘patriotism'.
"They decided that they had a monopoly on patriotism here.
"What do they have the right to determine here--what is patriotism and what it should be.
"Idiots, complete idiots.
"To remove the sign--with Bulgakov [great Russian writer--Master and Margarita--born in Kiev--CS]--is to pinch off some of your influence.
"To close the Bulgakov Museum is to tear off a piece of influence from oneself.
"To abandon the Russian language [Arestovich, like Zelensky, is a native
Russian speaker--CS] by the method of total bans is to lose
influence--on our main enemy.
"Exactly in this way, exactly under these slogans and from this picture
of the world, the largest military grouping in Europe, which we
inherited in 1991, was destroyed.
"All these dreams of isolation from the enemy, with whom we have
thousands of kilometers of a common border--and without natural
obstacles (!), hundreds of years of common history and an eternal desire
to devour us--nothing more stupid, infantile and helpless can be
imagined.
"They have not just imagined--they are trying to make it a strategy and still impose on us. And this is good.
"It doesn't even occur to them, dumb-headed, in their frog fuss (once,
the need is puffed up) that their weakness and inability to influence
real events are directly related to the voluntary rejection of
influence--through the constant desire for isolation.
"Influence is the ability to cause a backlash.
"If you seek to break the feedback from the main adversary, you are not affected.
"You create ideal conditions for the enemy to influence you.
"The snail strategy humiliates Ukraine. It demonstrates that Ukraine has the brains of a snail.
"I won't allow it. I need a Ukraine that plays across the entire
chessboard. Affects Moscow, Vladivostok, Beijing, Washington, and the
Martian settlement of Mask. And only in this way will Ukrainian culture
rise and be realized. Only in this way the Ukrainian language will
become fashionable--and studied. Only in this way will they want to
imitate us. Isolation is not imitated. Strength is imitated."
https://t.me/O_Arestovich_official/2533
An odd thing indeed to appear in such an official channel. One thing we
don't see in the Western press is the remarkable diversity of Ukrainian
society, which is made up of different cultures, languages, and points
of view, some of them very eccentric. Zelensky and most of his team are
Russian speakers from the East, and as I have written before, they were
elected on a platform of compromise and peace with Russia, a sharp
break from the confrontational policies of the previous US-sponsored
regime. The tension between Zelensky's party and the nationalist
factions in Ukrainian politics is huge, and as I have written before,
Zelensky is constrained in his actions by these elements. The
nationalist factions have little support among the people (as Arestovich
emphasizes in the quoted post) but they have a great deal of
muscle--they possess various far-right militias, which were used to
overthrow the Yanukovich government in 2014, and which can be used to
overthrow Zelensky. So you might imagine that Zelensky has a gun to his
head. I think these elements keep relatively quiet and line up behind
Zelensky only because Zelensky controls the pipeline of Western aid,
without which the country would collapse in a few minutes. But this can
change in a flash.
I'm not sure what this weird Telegram post portends--is a rupture coming
between Zelensky and Ukrainian nationalists? It's hard to say; the
proximate subject of this post is a relatively minor issue (in the
context of a big war)--whether or not to harbor the Russian dissident
Ilya Ponamarev. I have been afraid for a long time that Zelensky might
meet his end at the hands of his own nationalists.
It is possible that the current military situation is causing this
stress. There is a media blackout in the West, which was requested by
Ukraine, so we're not reading about it, but there are a lot of dramatic
events occurring right now on the ground. Yesterday, for example, it is
reported that Ukrainian commandos, in a large force, attempted to storm
the Zaporozhia nuclear power plant just before the UN inspectors
arrived, and large-scale Ukrainian attacks are going on in the outskirts
of Kherson, some of them achieving significant breakthroughs according
to Russian sources. Weird we don't read about it in our press.
Arestovich himself is a, well, strange figure. To say the least. He
was himself involved in far right (but not Ukrainian nationalist)
causes, and was even some kind of follower of Dugin at one point (there
is a video from the early 2000s where Arestovich appears on a panel with
Dugin at one of Dugin's "Eurasianism" conferences). Arestovich was the
deputy head of the far-right group "Bratstvo" at one point, an
organization described by its founder (the even stranger Dmytro
Korchynsky https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dmytro_Korchynsky
) as the "Orthodox Taliban" [!!]. Arestovich's professional background
is in acting, then psychology, a student of psychology and astrology,
and oddly seems to have found work as a military advisor [!], then
military intelligence officer, then propagandist. See: https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/odr/ukraine-president-adviser-arestovych/
JE comments: This is the head-scratcher of the day. What exactly is
Arestovich trying to achieve? Even more confusing, his interpretation
of how things got to this point makes no sense. It all seems to hinge
on Arestovich's notion of "influence," but how? That the
ultra-nationalists rejected Russian culture itself (as in Bulgakov),
thus sparking the invasion? Or that they are destroying the moral
influence they have in this war (hence Moscow, Beijing, Washington),
which undermines the Ukrainian military effort?
Zelensky needs the martial zeal of the ultra-nationalists, but he also
has to keep them from turning against him. A screed like this one from
Arestovich may be many things, but smart politics isn't one of them.
Winter is coming within mere weeks and no matter what else, surely the burden of finding warmth and power in Ukraine is soon to become intolerable. A human catastrophe is rising for certain. The question is, what does the West do now when Putin and Russia again offer to talk?
Shutting off the power in the rump Ukrainian state will cause a mass exodus to flee for refuge to Poland and Germany, this will be a disaster unparalleled in recent European history. Just the attendant collapse in telecommunications will make the place a madhouse. You can well imagine the rest. Already there are queues for water in Nikolaev, and who knows where else. How does queueing for water, if there is any, in temperatures of minus-20C to minus-40C sound?
Poland and Germany absorbing the cold freezing hungry Ukraine refugees sounds like a non-starter despite their energetic support to date. Of course the Ukrainians will need to be told how to shower by the Germans so as to save fuel.
Lots of commentators believe the time for talking is over, at least until Odessa is taken. They may be right. But Putin has been steadily measured and deliberate throughout, ratcheting up the pain, and that ratcheting is going to rise very very fast with the cold weather and lack of power. What happens when millions of people are freezing to death at the Polish border as US citizens go to the polls in November? Will Biden and Blinken and Nuland try to bring an anti-Russia hysteria into the polling booth, nuclear war be damned? Or will people begin to see the huge risks facing us all and publicly demand a stop to further madness?